Join Our email list

Join our email list to be updated on upcoming events and new menu items.

Email List 

Pies

Banana Cream Pie

$21.00

9inch, Classic Banana Pudding in a pie. You can choose the crust, nilla wafer crust or all butter flour crust.

Caramel Apple Pie

$21.00

Double crust with caramel mixed with Honey crisps and Fuji Apples or Crumb topping mixed with Honey crisps and Fuji apples.

Lemon Chiffon Pie

$21.00

Lighty tart lemon cream with sweet whipped cream on all butter crust or graham cracker crust.

French Silk Pie

$21.00

Smooth and light chocolate filling, topped with homemade whipped cream and chocolate curls.

Cherry Pie

$15.00

9 inch pie. You have the option to have double-crust cherry pie or crumb topped cherry pie.

Chocolate Cream Pie

$15.00

Old Fashion Chocolate Cream Pie. Chocolatey cream with an Oreo crust.

Testimonials

About Us

Finest Pie Shop in Merrillville

At Sue & Kim’s Pies, you’ll find a dazzling selection of colorful, luscious handmade pies, made by our expert bakers right here in Merrillville. Call 219-779-2140 to speak to one of our friendly staff, who will do their best to assist you in your order. Please allow one business day for orders, and all pies are freshly baked. We can deliver or arrange for pickup. Our pies are made with our all-butter crust or our homemade graham cracker crust. Cream pies are topped with our homemade whipped cream. We can top other pies upon request.

About Me

I'm Kim. The name Sue & Kim's Pies is my way to honor my mother, Sue. Most of the recipes I used are from her. So it made sense to name my business Sue & Kim's Pies. I learned from my mom that besides the right quality ingredients, you need to love what you do. I love to use fresh fruits and quality ingredients. This is what sets me apart from the rest. Homemade, handmade, delicious Pies made with love and great ingredients.

Frequently Asked Questions

 1. Where are you located? 

We are located in
Merrillville, IN. 

2. How do I order from you? 

You can order by phone
or website. 

3. How long will it take to get my order? 

My pies are baked to order. You will get the pie the next day. 

4. What are the hours of operation? 

Mon- Fri 9 am- 7pm,
Sat 9am-5pm, Sun closed 

You can still place an
order on Sunday through the website. 

5. How would I get my order? 

We offer delivery and
pick up, free delivery in a 15-mile radius, and a $10.00 delivery fee if you
are outside our range.  

6. Are you certified? 

I am ServSafe
certified, and my certificate number is 12888031. 

7. Why do your pies cost so much? 

All of the pies are
handmade, using fresh ingredients and a family recipe. 

8. Do you offer discounts? 

Yes, I offer several
discounts. First-time customers 10% off (must be mention on phone orders only). 

Referral Program, you
refer someone. Both will get 10% off. 

I also have a reward
program. After the sixth visit, you can get 30% off your order. (rewards and
discounts cannot be used together.) 

Amenities

Parking available
Accept debit/credit cards
Delivery Available
Pick up Available
Spoken languages:
English

Send a Message

An email will be sent to the owner

Please note that Sue & Kim’s Pies LLC may not be able to honor booking requests made.

Areas Covered

NWI

Opening Hours

Monday

-

Tuesday

-

Wednesday

-

Thursday

-

Friday

-

Saturday

-

Today
Closed