Sue & Kim's Pies' Story

Finest Pie Shop in Merrillville

At Sue & Kim's Pies LLC, All of the pies are made from scratch. I mean, everything is made from scratch, from our whipped cream down to the crust. And I ...

Read more

About Me

Hi, I'm Kim. I am the owner of Sue & Kim's Pies LLC. I serve delicious, buttery, and flaky homemade pies. I have been baking since I was a teenager. I ...

Read more

Frequently Asked Questions


 1. Where are you located?...

Read more
Important News

Ordering for Thanksgiving is closed!!!

***All Pies are Baked to Order***
1 Point for every visit and after the 6th visit, you will get 20% off your total.

Pies

Fruit Pies
Classic Apple Pie

Classic Apple Pie with a mix of honey crisps and fuji apples on 9 inch all butter crust.

$16.00
Caramel Apple Pie

9 inch Crumb topping mixed with Honey crisps, Fuji apples and Caramel.

$21.00
Dutch Apple Pie

Classic Apple Pie with a Crumb topping on 9 inch all butter crust.

$21.00
Cream Pies
Key Lime Pie

The perfect balance of sweet and tart on 9 inch graham cracker crust and topped with homemade whipped cream and lime zest. 

$15.00
Banana Cream Pie

Classic Banana Pudding in a pie. Creamy custard with a layer of bananas topped with homemade whipped cream on a 9 inch wafer crust.  

$21.00
Lemon Chiffon Pie

Lightly sweet and tart lemon cream with sweet whipped cream on 9 inch graham cracker crust.  

$21.00

Happy Customers

KW
Purchased a classic apple pie and a Dutch Apple I bought the Dutch for me and it barely lasted a week lol my friend loved her classic as well so for you apple pie lovers don’t hesitate I ...
Read more
Kiare W.
KW
Purchased a classic apple pie and a Dutch Apple I bought the Dutch for me and it barely lasted a week lol my friend loved her classic as well so for you apple pie lovers don’t hesitate I ...
Read more
Kiare W.
PH
These are the best pies you could ever eat.
Patrice H.
PH
These are the best pies you could ever eat.
Patrice H.

Amenities

  • Parking available
  • Accept debit/credit cards
  • Delivery Available
  • Pick up Available
Spoken languages:
English

Google Reviews

Tracy Eleczko

12 July 2021
4 months ago
I ordered a custard pie for my mom. She used to get hers at Bakers Square. The one by us closed so I tried Schereville. They no longer make the custard pies. I ...
Read more

Dan Stunkel

20 June 2021
5 months ago
Delicious cherry pie! We will definitely be ordering again! Thanks Sue & Kim’s Pie’s!

Contact Form

An email will be sent to the owner

Please note that Sue & Kim’s Pies LLC may not be able to honor booking requests made.

Hours

Sunday

-

Monday

-

Tuesday

-

Wednesday

-

Thursday

-

Friday

-

Saturday

-

Open
Today