Reviews

Add review

Alex Rosales

23 May 2023

8 days ago

Ordered twice here already and my wife loves it! I even had a piece and I hate pie. Will definitely be ordering again.

Claudia Marie

29 March 2023

2 months ago

My first order was of my favorite, the sweet potatoe pie. It was delish. The crust and texture were prefect! Then I ordered the banana cream pie. OMG another hi...

Mary Vincent

06 December 2022

6 months ago

Lemon chiffon pie was absolutely AMAZING! We usually order Marylyn’s but they blew them out of the water. Can’t wait to try other pies.

Angela Marcell Popovich

21 November 2022

6 months ago

Great banana cream pie! Great service.

Krista Lefchak

10 September 2022

9 months ago

Best pies in NWI! Ordered the triple berry and French silk and both were absolutely delicious. I love that they are homemade and made to order. Placing the o...

Cat Lover

09 August 2022

10 months ago

Support a local business Homemade pies We tried the blueberry pie! Will be ordering again soon!

Cat Lover

08 August 2022

10 months ago

First time try their amazing pies. Blueberry is wonderful. Can't wait to buy more of them.

Patrice Penro-henderson

26 June 2022

a year ago

I cannot say enough about Sue and Kim pies, everything I ordered was delicious, I had the pecan pie, the caramel apple pie, and they also make cookies my absolu...

Jason Annes

21 June 2022

a year ago

My dad was craving a banana cream pie for Father’s Day. I searched Pie shops and found Sue & Kim’s and decided to take the plunge. This is not my favorite type ...

Gia Camp

15 June 2022

a year ago

I ordered 1 sweet potato pie and 1 pecan pie and they both were absolutely delicious and FRESH I must add they were also very balanced in flavor and I could tel...

lezlie walton

29 May 2022

a year ago

Everything is so good 5 star all the way😋😋😋😋

Robin Stephen

26 May 2022

a year ago

Ordered the key lime pie the other day, me and my wife enjoyed it very much—seems like a quality product, recommended

C4tnip83

16 May 2022

a year ago

Vanessa Kegley

05 May 2022

a year ago

We ordered a key lime pie and a strawberry pie for Easter. They were both fantastic! Highly recommend! Easy to order and ready on time. Thank you again!

sara duncan

19 February 2022

a year ago

Absolutely fantastic! Can’t believe I ordered this pie last night to cheer up my husband and it was delivered to my door by 11am today! Thanks so much for this ...

Matthew Whiteman

09 January 2022

a year ago

My mom made a special request for her 60th birthday: A banana cream pie! Not too many places make *real* banana cream pie, so I was excited to try Sue & Kim's w...

jeffangie1000

30 December 2021

a year ago

First time trying this bakery and my family was very happy with the way they turned out and said I better bring these for all the family events

Tracy Eleczko

12 July 2021

2 years ago

I ordered a custard pie for my mom. She used to get hers at Bakers Square. The one by us closed so I tried Schereville. They no longer make the custard pies. I ...

Dan Stunkel

20 June 2021

2 years ago

Delicious cherry pie! We will definitely be ordering again! Thanks Sue & Kim’s Pie’s!

Paulette Pohlmeyer

14 June 2021

2 years ago

kiare walton

06 June 2021

2 years ago

I love apple pies and her Dutch apple pie is very delicious

Nicholas Denysenko

09 May 2021

2 years ago

Bought a chocolate cream pie for Orthodox Easter last week. Fresh, tasty, excellent dessert, friendly, great customer service.

J ADDISON

22 April 2021

2 years ago

Great

David Nelson

31 March 2021

2 years ago

Will Will

31 March 2021

2 years ago

If you want a pie with that homemade goodness then Sue & Kim’s Pies is where you need too go!!!! Excellent service! Great quality! With reasonable prices! My fa...

Kyla Pearson

29 December 2020

2 years ago

The Key Lime Pie was everything. I will order another one very soon!!!

Keep It Cute

23 December 2020

2 years ago

Great customer service, reasonably priced, delicious, buttery, flakey pies! What more could you ask for? P. S. The caramel apple pie is to die for. Thank me lat...

Luke Woodke

31 October 2020

3 years ago